Quick answer
Retinol has decades of research behind it and often works faster, but it can irritate. Bakuchiol is a plant-based alternative that gave similar results with less scaling and stinging in one randomised trial on photoageing, although it hasn't been proven equal to retinol for acne scars. If your skin is sensitive or already inflamed, bakuchiol is the gentler place to start, and a patch test is wise with either one.
Retinol vs bakuchiol: which is better?
Retinol and bakuchiol are both used to improve the look of acne scars by supporting collagen and cell turnover, but they aren't interchangeable. Retinol has decades of clinical backing and often works faster on deeper texture. Bakuchiol is gentler: in the one head-to-head trial, which looked at photoageing, results were similar with less irritation, which matters for post-acne skin that is already inflamed. Neither repairs the skin barrier on its own. That is where a simple, fragrance-conscious moisturiser like tallow comes in, as a supporting layer under or after either one.
Why I ended up making this at all: I was studying at Formula Botanica, working through ingredients one at a time. I was almost 40, and I'd started wondering what the alternative to retinol was — because I didn't want to use retinol. Bakuchiol kept coming up, in several different brands. But I was already using tallow and loved it, and I didn't want to switch. So the idea came naturally: combine the two, take the best of both. That's how Fancy Rose was born. — Laura, founder
What Causes Acne Scarring, Briefly
Acne scars form when inflammation from a breakout damages the collagen structure in the dermis. As the wound heals, the body either produces too little collagen (leaving behind atrophic, "ice pick" or "boxcar" depressions) or too much (raised, hypertrophic scars). Post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation (PIH) — the flat red or brown marks left after a spot heals — is technically not a scar, but it's often lumped in with scarring because it responds to some of the same ingredients.
This is why retinoids and retinoid-like compounds show up so often in acne-scar conversations: anything that reliably increases collagen turnover and controls pigment-producing cells has a shot at improving both true scarring and PIH.
It's worth separating the two before buying anything. PIH generally fades on its own over months, and responds well to ingredients that calm inflammation and even out pigment. True atrophic or hypertrophic scarring is a structural change in the dermis — it needs sustained collagen remodeling, which is a slower process regardless of which active you choose. If you're not sure which one you're dealing with, flat marks that change color with sun exposure are usually PIH; depressions or raised bumps you can feel with a fingertip are usually true scarring.
How Retinol Works on Acne Scars
Retinol is a vitamin A derivative that converts to retinoic acid in the skin. Retinoic acid binds to nuclear receptors in skin cells, which speeds up cell turnover, reduces hyperpigmentation, and — most relevant for scarring — stimulates fibroblasts to lay down new, more organised collagen. At a molecular level, retinoic acid is a known regulator of collagen deposition, partly through inhibiting TGF-β signalling, the same pathway implicated in scar formation (Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology, 2025).
Clinically, a combination of retinoic acid and glycolic acid has shown measurable improvement in atrophic acne scars in controlled trials (PMC, retinoic acid + glycolic acid acne scar study), and reviews of topical retinoids consistently report collagen remodeling on histology after 12+ weeks of use. Retinol is genuinely one of the best-studied ingredients in dermatology for this purpose — that track record is real.
The trade-off is what it feels like to live with. Redness, flaking, stinging, and a temporary "purge" period (2–6 weeks) are common, and retinoid irritation has been shown to trigger real inflammatory cytokine release and barrier breakdown while your skin adjusts (strategies to reduce retinoid-induced irritation, 2024). It's also not compatible with pregnancy or breastfeeding, since oral vitamin A derivatives carry known developmental risks and there's no established "safe" topical dose.
How Bakuchiol Works on Acne Scars
Bakuchiol is a plant-derived compound from Psoralea corylifolia seeds. Despite having no structural resemblance to retinoids, it was shown in gene-expression profiling to activate many of the same skin pathways as retinol — hence its reputation as a "retinol-like" ingredient (Chaudhuri & Bojanowski, International Journal of Cosmetic Science, 2014).
The most relevant head-to-head evidence is a randomised, double-blind trial that compared bakuchiol twice daily against retinol once daily, at matched strengths, over 12 weeks for photoageing (lines, pigmentation, elasticity — the same texture markers that overlap with scar improvement). Both groups saw statistically significant, similarly-sized improvement, but the bakuchiol group reported significantly less scaling and stinging (Dhaliwal et al., British Journal of Dermatology, 2019). Separate research on bakuchiol's effect on facial ageing mechanisms found it modulates several of the same cellular pathways retinoids target, without the same irritant profile (multidirectional activity of bakuchiol, 2022).
Honest gap: that trial measured photoaging, not acne scarring specifically — there is currently no large, controlled, head-to-head trial testing bakuchiol against retinol for acne scars alone. Some small pilot studies combining bakuchiol with salicylic acid have reported meaningful reductions in active acne lesions after six weeks, which is encouraging but not the same claim as "fades established scars." Anyone telling you the science on bakuchiol-for-scars is fully settled is overstating it — the ingredient is promising and well-tolerated, not proven equivalent for this specific use case.
Retinol vs bakuchiol side by side
| Factor | Retinol | Bakuchiol |
|---|---|---|
| Clinical evidence base | Extensive, decades of trials | Growing, smaller sample sizes |
| Speed of visible results | Often faster (8–12 weeks) | Comparable but sometimes slower |
| Irritation / purging | Common, can be significant | Minimal in trials |
| Sun sensitivity | Increases photosensitivity | Not significantly photosensitising |
| Pregnancy / breastfeeding | Not recommended | Considered lower-risk, but data is limited — check with your doctor |
| Best suited for | Tolerant skin wanting fastest results | Sensitive, reactive, or already-inflamed post-acne skin |
Is bakuchiol as good as retinol?
Not proven for acne scars, but promising. In a 12-week randomised, double-blind trial on photoageing, bakuchiol and retinol gave similar improvement in lines and pigmentation, and the bakuchiol group reported less scaling and stinging (Dhaliwal et al., 2019). That trial did not look at acne scars, and retinol still has the much larger evidence base. So bakuchiol is a fair, gentler choice rather than a proven equal. For the full ingredient story, read Bakuchiol: The Natural Alternative to Retinol Without Irritation.
Can you use bakuchiol while pregnant?
Retinol is not recommended during pregnancy or breastfeeding. Bakuchiol is generally considered lower-risk, but safety data in pregnancy is limited, so please ask your doctor or midwife before using it or any new skincare product.
So Which Bakuchiol Product Should You Actually Buy?
Deciding bakuchiol is the easy part. The harder question is which format — because bakuchiol products split into two genuinely different things, and the right one depends on whether your post-acne skin also needs its barrier rebuilt. Here is an honest look at the options, including where ours is not the right answer.
Paula's Choice CLINICAL Retinol + Bakuchiol Treatment
Best for: tolerant skin that wants both actives at once, buffered with ceramides and peptides.
What it isn't: a bakuchiol-only product. It still contains retinol — so the irritation risk and the pregnancy restriction come back with it. If you chose bakuchiol specifically to avoid those, this isn't your pick.
Verdict: the strongest option if your skin already handles retinol well and you want maximum activity.
Typology Bakuchiol Serum
Best for: people who want a short, readable ingredient list — bakuchiol with squalane and hazelnut oil, nothing else. Made in France, so easy to get within the EU.
What it isn't: a moisturiser. It's a serum, which means you still need a barrier-supporting cream over it — two products, two steps, two things that can irritate.
Verdict: a clean, simple way into bakuchiol if you already have a moisturiser you trust.
Herbivore Bakuchiol Serum
Best for: those who want bakuchiol paired with peptides in a plant-based formula.
What it isn't: European. Shipping and import duties into the EU can cost more than the serum, and like any serum it still needs a moisturiser over it.
Verdict: a good formula, but the least practical option if you're buying from Belgium or the Netherlands.
Nana Latta Tallow Butter Fancy Rose — bakuchiol + rosehip in a tallow base (€36,90)
Best for: post-acne skin that needs the barrier rebuilt as well as the active — bakuchiol and rosehip CO2 extract carried in grass-fed tallow made in Belgium, so the active and the barrier repair happen in one step instead of two.
What it isn't: a serum. If you want something lightweight to layer underneath a separate cream, this isn't it — it is the step. Fancy Rose is complete care: nothing else goes over it, no moisturizer needed.
Verdict: the right pick when your skin is inflamed and stripped from acne treatment and you want fewer products on it, not more.
Compared at a glance
| Product | Format | What else you need | Easy to buy in the EU? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paula's Choice CLINICAL | Serum, with retinol added | A moisturiser on top | Yes |
| Typology | Serum | A moisturiser on top | Yes (France) |
| Herbivore | Serum | A moisturiser on top | Import from US |
| Nana Latta Fancy Rose | Complete care | No moisturizer needed | Yes (Belgium) |
★★★★★
“Smells amazing and really hydrates your skinn well, love the product!”
Jana Vervoort · verified Judge.me review of Tallow Butter Fancy Rose
The verdict
If your skin tolerates actives and you want the strongest formula, the Paula's Choice hybrid wins — but you're accepting retinol's irritation back into the equation. If you want bakuchiol in a short, simple serum and already own a moisturiser you trust, Typology is the easiest one to get hold of in Europe.
But the reason most people land on this page is post-acne skin that is already inflamed, stripped and reactive from months of acne treatment. For that skin, adding a serum on top of a compromised barrier is often what causes the next flare. That's the case for Tallow Butter Fancy Rose (€36,90) — bakuchiol delivered in something that also rebuilds the barrier, so it's one step instead of two, with no moisturizer needed over it. Handmade in Belgium, ships across the EU.
Where Tallow Fits Into a Retinol or Bakuchiol Routine
Tallow itself is a complete skincare product — its fatty acid profile (oleic, palmitic, and stearic acids) closely mirrors what skin already produces, so on its own it can moisturise and support barrier repair without needing anything else underneath. Many Nana Latta customers use nothing but tallow, full stop.
That said, if you already use a retinol or bakuchiol serum and don't want to give it up, tallow works well as a final step on top. Both retinol and bakuchiol can leave skin slightly drier or more barrier-compromised while it adjusts, and tallow's job in that context is simple: seal in whatever active you applied underneath and support the skin barrier while it recovers. This is a reassurance for people already committed to a layered routine — not a suggestion that layering is necessary. If you'd rather keep things simple, plain tallow before bed does most of the same barrier-support job without the extra step.
How to Start Either Ingredient Without Wrecking Your Barrier
Most of the bad reviews for retinol (and, less often, bakuchiol) aren't really about the ingredient failing — they're about the skin barrier getting overwhelmed before it had a chance to adjust. A few practical points that come directly out of the irritation-reduction literature:
Patch test first. Put a small amount on the inside of your forearm or behind your ear for a couple of days before using it on your face, especially if your skin reacts easily.
Start slow. Two to three nights a week for the first two to three weeks, not nightly. This applies more to retinol than bakuchiol, but both benefit from a gradual introduction on skin that's already inflamed from active breakouts.
Buffer, don't stack actives. Applying a moisturiser first, letting it absorb, then applying the retinol or bakuchiol on top blunts irritation without meaningfully reducing efficacy — this "sandwich" approach is a commonly cited strategy in the dermatology literature on reducing retinoid-induced irritation.
Don't combine with other exfoliating actives at the same time. Layering retinol with strong acids or physical scrubs while skin is already scarred and inflamed is one of the most common ways people end up with more irritation and no faster results.
Give it the full trial period before judging. Both ingredients need 8–12 weeks minimum before you can fairly assess whether they're working on your scars specifically — quitting at week three because nothing's changed yet is the most common reason people conclude "this didn't work for me."
Skin-Type Breakdown
Dry skin: Retinol can be genuinely harsh on dry skin until a strong moisture barrier is established. Bakuchiol's gentler profile makes it the easier starting point, paired with a rich tallow balm at night.
Oily / acne-prone skin: Retinol's faster cell turnover can be an advantage here, but the purge phase is often worse on oily, breakout-prone skin. Non-comedogenic tallow formulas — like Tallow + Jojoba Minimalist Butter (€28,90) — help offset dryness from either active without clogging pores.
Sensitive skin: Bakuchiol is generally the better-tolerated starting point based on the trial data above. Pair with an unscented, fragrance-free moisturiser rather than one with added essential oils to avoid stacking irritants.
Post-acne / scarred skin (already inflamed): This is the kind of skin that may do better with bakuchiol's lower irritation, as seen in the Dhaliwal trial on photoageing. Actively inflamed skin doesn't need an additional irritant on top of the breakout itself.
Mature skin: Both actives show comparable collagen-support effects for combined ageing-and-scarring concerns; retinol's stronger evidence base may edge it ahead if your skin already tolerates actives well.
Not Ready to Decide Yet?
Get 10% off your first order when you join the Nana Latta list, plus first access to new products and restocks. Join the list here.
Product Recommendations
- Tallow Butter Fancy Rose — with Bakuchiol & Rosehip Extract (€36,90): our bestselling face cream, already formulated with bakuchiol for people who want the ingredient without adding a separate serum step.
- Tallow + Jojoba Minimalist Butter, Unscented (€28,90): award-winning, non-comedogenic, formulated for sensitive, acne-prone and oily skin — a good layer to offset retinol dryness without new fragrance irritants.
- Tallow Butter Family Daisy (€36,90): our gentlest formula, suited to skin that's currently reactive from active ingredients and needs pure barrier support.
★★★★★
“This is the best product I've ever purchased for my skin. I'm 35 and have sensitive skin, acne-prone, rosacea, and very dry in winter. I was concerned about breaking out with this butter but it actually had the opposite effect - my skin is clear and no longer dry!”
Danielle · verified Judge.me review of Tallow + Jojoba Minimalist Butter
Related Reads
- Bakuchiol: The Natural Alternative to Retinol Without Irritation
- Tallow and Bakuchiol: The Natural Anti-Ageing Combination Europe Has Been Missing
- Best Tallow Skincare Brands 2026: An Honest Global Comparison
- Tallow and Honey Balm for Acne: Helpful or Hype?
- Does Beef Tallow Help Acne? The Honest Answer
FAQ
Retinol vs bakuchiol: which is better?
It depends on your skin. Retinol has the most research behind it and often works faster, but it irritates more often. Bakuchiol is milder and suits sensitive or already inflamed skin better, although it is not proven equal to retinol for acne scars. Pick one, give it 8–12 weeks, and patch test first.
Is bakuchiol as good as retinol?
For photoageing markers (fine lines, pigmentation, elasticity), a randomised controlled trial found similar results with significantly less irritation (Dhaliwal et al., 2019). For acne scarring specifically, the evidence is smaller and less direct: promising, not proven equivalent.
Which bakuchiol product is best for acne scars?
It depends on whether your skin also needs barrier repair. If it tolerates actives well, the Paula's Choice hybrid is the strongest formula, though it reintroduces retinol. For bakuchiol in a short, minimal serum, Typology is the easiest to buy in Europe. For post-acne skin that's inflamed and stripped, a bakuchiol balm that also supports the barrier, like Nana Latta's Fancy Rose, means one step instead of two, with no moisturizer needed over it.
Can I use retinol and bakuchiol together?
There's no strong clinical reason to combine them, and doing so mostly raises irritation risk without proven added benefit. Most dermatology guidance suggests picking one and giving it 8–12 weeks before judging results.
How long does it take to see acne scar improvement from retinol or bakuchiol?
Studies generally measure results at 8–12 weeks at the earliest, and some follow people for longer. Neither ingredient produces overnight change, because collagen remodeling is a slow biological process.
Can you use bakuchiol while pregnant?
Retinol is not recommended during pregnancy or breastfeeding, due to established risks with vitamin A derivatives. Bakuchiol is generally considered lower-risk, but safety data in pregnancy is still limited, so check with your doctor or midwife before using either.
Can I use tallow at the same time as retinol or bakuchiol?
Yes. Tallow doesn't interact negatively with either ingredient. If you already use one, tallow works well as a final layer to support the skin barrier while it adjusts. If you don't use either, tallow alone still supports barrier repair and moisture without needing a retinoid at all.
Will retinol or bakuchiol get rid of deep, pitted acne scars?
Both can improve texture and shallow atrophic scarring over time, but deep ice-pick or boxcar scars typically need in-clinic treatments (microneedling, lasers, subcision) for significant change. Topical actives are a supporting tool, not a substitute for those procedures in more severe cases.
Should I patch test retinol or bakuchiol?
Yes, with any new active. Apply a small amount to the inside of your forearm or behind your ear for a couple of days before using it on your face, and stop if you see redness, itching or stinging.
Ready to Simplify the Rest of Your Routine?
Whichever active you choose, the moisturising step underneath it doesn't need to be complicated. Shop Tallow Butter Fancy Rose (€36,90) — bakuchiol, rosehip, and grass-fed tallow, made in Belgium, in one jar.
